25,573 Job Cancelled, Calcutta High Court’s Decision Alters Electoral Dynamics in West Bengal

Ex Justice Abhijit Ganguly
Preeti Bali / 11:00 am / April 25, 2024

A ruling from the Calcutta High Court has invalidated the appointment of 25,373 educators and associated personnel via a state-endorsed examination in 2016, citing instances where numerous applicants secured positions through bribery.

The verdict has set off a chain of events poised to reshape the electoral landscape between West Bengal’s primary political rivals, the Trinamool Congress led by Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s leadership.

Long-standing Allegations Culminate in Legal Action

The legal proceedings stemmed from allegations of corruption surrounding the State Service Commission examination, a case that has endured for an extended period. In July 2022, the Enforcement Directorate (ED) apprehended Partha Chatterjee, the Trinamool’s general secretary and a minister in the state administration at the time, in connection with the matter.

Significant Seizures and Ongoing Repercussions

Investigators seized more than ₹28 crore in cash and over 5 kilograms of gold from premises linked to Chatterjee shortly before his arrest. The recent court ruling on the purported recruitment impropriety constitutes another setback for Mamata Banerjee, who was already contending with allegations of misconduct and land acquisition by her party’s functionaries or supporters in Sandeshkhali, drawing nationwide attention to the severity of the charges.

Implications of the High Court Verdict on Teacher Recruitment

The cancellation of nearly 26,000 positions in one fell swoop, notwithstanding the potential for legal recourse through higher courts, not only impacts the individuals affected but also reverberates within their respective households. Moreover, it casts uncertainty over the education of government school students and stirs unrest among their parents.

For instance, reports from Murshidabad district suggest that Arjunpur High School in Farakka block, housing over ten thousand students, lost 36 instructors in a single stroke. The court not only mandates the dismissal of appointees from the 2016 recruitment examination but also calls for a fresh round of assessments to fill the ensuing vacancies.

While many deserving candidates, who succeeded in the examination on their own merit, now find themselves inadvertently penalized, protests have erupted against the blanket annulment of appointments. Concurrently, a five-member panel representing dismissed employees engaged with officials from the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education to address the unfolding crisis.

Unresolved Appeals and Political Maneuvering

Notably, the court ruling fails to address crucial appeals from candidates contesting the validity of the appointments, leaving them potentially compelled to re-sit the examination. The ensuing legal battle between opposing factions, backed by political entities benefitting from electoral bonds, promises protracted contention without clear victory.

The BJP has escalated accusations of corruption against the Trinamool Congress, while the latter retaliates by alleging the BJP’s interference in judicial affairs. Mamata Banerjee reaffirms her support for those adversely affected by the ruling, even as BJP leader Suvendu Adhikari forecasts repercussions for the Trinamool Congress in the near future.

Uncertain Electoral Ramifications

Questions arise concerning the role of dismissed educators who were slated to serve as polling officers, adding complexity to an already tense electoral climate. The ongoing strife between the TMC and BJP may sway undecided voters, shaping perceptions of Mamata Banerjee’s administration as either culpable or victimized by political machinations.

The upcoming election results on June 4 will illuminate whether voters perceive the TMC as a responsible governing body or a victim of partisan antagonism, potentially influencing the emergence of a third coalition comprising the Indian National Congress and the Left Front.

While TMC and BJP remain the frontrunners in West Bengal, the Congress-Left alliance has yet to gain significant traction. With polling scheduled across seven phases, the electoral stakes are higher than ever in the contentious battle for West Bengal’s 42 Lok Sabha seats, a crucial battleground for the BJP’s electoral ambitions.

More Stories